Graphics Graphics Style vote

[Whitespirits]

Hey guys which of these do you think is better ?

 

 

 

Just messing around with the pokemon like styles

[Mcadams]

2

[Phenomenal]

Second one  

[Damian666]

yep, second.

[Beefy Kasplant]

Second is about hundred times nicer 

[panda]

2 is infinitely nicer

1 looks like I made it

[Giligis]

Yeah I have to say 2 myself it's very nice. 

[Kibbelz]

I think its obvious thats its number 2. Is that set a pokemon spinoff/free comercially? Since it doesn't look the same as the old ds graphics from memory.

[Whitespirits]

ye its a custom set, quite cool

[Kibbelz]

Linky?

[Mighty Professional]

2

[Xeno]

Second one imho

 

[jcsnider]

I guess I'm going with the crowd: 2

[emptyaccount]

The second one

[Sethis]

I'm actually going against the flow here, but it's a good ol' 1 for me, especially if it's supposed to look pokemon-ish.

 

Truth to be told, both looks great and i'd rather use the second myself for a more classic RPG game - and it seem more detailled - but for a pokemon-like game, definitely the first one (more cartoon-ish).

 

PS : beside, after comparing the two, i can't help but think that the sprite doesn't "belong" to the second one ... it might be just me though ...

[Zetasis]

Well, I have to go with 1 as well. I personally only choose 1 because it looks more unique. The second one looks way to much like pokemon but if that's what you're aiming for then I guess 2 works. I've always just been more of a fan of unique art, even if it isn't professional quality. Hope that makes sense...

[SkywardRiver]

You could make a commercial game with either and people would buy it. Personally I like the pallet of two but the structure of 1.

[Gibier]

Personnally i think the second is tge best choice with character like this.

[Ranqe]

Second one all the way! xD

[Colonello]

Like everyone else, second for sure!

[Tashology]

Definitely second. I love the cartoony look but the second one is a lot more precise and prettier.

[Aliensaliva]

I'd say one but with bigger trees. Yes, two looks more aesthetically pleasing, but one just looks playful and fun.

[Whitespirits]

 

I noticed Celianna had some farm/cartoon style tilesets that are better scale than 200% pokemon, what do you think of this?

[jcsnider]

I don't think that one should even be up for consideration. 

[Kibbelz]

21 minutes ago, jcsnider said:

I don't think that one should even be up for consideration. 

Curious, why not? Its not like he cares about licencing if he's making a fan based game?